GRANTSVILLE PARKING FINES CAUSE OF SUIT - Postalwait Claims Constitutional Violation

(07/17/2002)
A civil suit was filed yesterday against the Town of Grantsville regarding collection of $2 parking fines. Kevin B. Postalwait, a Grantsville attorney and public defender, claims the town has denied him due process, among other irregularities.

"This would be an easy thing to ignore, but I felt the town should not continue to violate the constitutional rights of people who have business there," Postalwait said. "Besides, each ticket would be processed separately, which could cost someone a lot of money."

Postalwait doesn't deny the town's right to collect parking fines, but states he was never summoned before Municipal Court, nor did any warrant command his appearance in what the State of West Virginia says is a criminal matter.

Mayor Gary Knight told The Hur Herald the town is "not utilizing city court to collect delinquent parking meter fines because it does not have the right to issue warrants," which Postalwait says is not true.

Postalwait contends no legal judgment has been entered against him for which he is civilly liable, because a parking ticket is viewed as a criminal offense and a defendant is entitled to a criminal hearing in which the "burden of proof is beyond a reasonable doubt."

"In my case, there is plenty of reasonable doubt," he said. "That is why I filed the suit, since I've been deprived of defending myself."

Mayor Gary Knight and Court Recorder Pat Starkey turned eight unpaid $2 tickets over to Calhoun Magistrate Court for collection. Added fines or costs total $37 on each ticket.

Postalwait said the town ignored people with multiple tickets, somehow targeting individuals who have apparently received one ticket.

Knight said the town may have made a mistake processing the tickets through Magistrate Court, saying "We are now pursuing plans to seek relief through Circuit Court" for the $2 tickets. SEE ARTICLE WITH KNIGHT'S COMMENTS

Postalwait's suit asks he be awarded the costs of the action and reasonable attorney fees. It also calls for damages for the violation of constitutional rights, also calling for punitive damages related to willful and malicious actions.

The suit requests a jury trial.